Measure for Measure was a play written by William Shakespeare in the
early 17th century. Shadows and Fog was a movie written and directed by
Woody Allen in the late 20th century. Considering that the two works were
written in very different time periods, it would be expected that the role
of women would be very different in each work. This is exactly what is
observed when the two works are compared in regards to their female
characters and the roles of women that are suggested by these characters,
their actions, and their qualities. Measure for Measure presents a view
where women are pure and not expected to be promiscuous, where women are
dependant on men, and where women have few options or choices. In
contrast, Shadows and Fog presents a view where women are promiscuous
rather than pure, where woman are independent from men, and where women
have almost unlimited freedom. These three major differences will now be
considered by comparing the female characters in the two works, including
their actions, their qualities, and what is expected of them.
The first difference observed with the role of women is related to
whether women are expected to be pure or promiscuous. In Measure for
Measure, the major female character is Isabella. She represents a very
pure female character. This is first seen at the start of the play by the
fact that she is training to become a nun and by the strong Christian
values she appears to have. This is then emphasized later when she is told
her brother's life will be saved if she agrees to sleep with Angelo. She
refuses this offer, placing her chastity and her Christian values above her
own life. This illustrates that a woman's purity is highly valued, while a
woman being promiscuous is not accepted. Mariana is another female
character in the play and she is quite different to Isabella. Unlike
Isabella, she does not value her chast...