Rhetoric and persuasive argument has been used since the inception of
human language, from Greek philosophers in ancient Athens to religious
sages in the Far East. Persons who feel strongly about their opinions have
a right and in perhaps a responsibility to express their views and to try
and influence the minds of others. Persuasion engages people in dialogue
and debate, which are natural and healthy forms of interpersonal
communication. In fact, effective persuasion can change the course of
history: had Columbus not persuaded Queen Isabella to fund his journey, the
world would look much different today.
Persuasion is an inherently ethical process because it creates
dialogue and invites people to examine their own interests and beliefs. It
forces those who would listen to be open-minded and to examine issues they
might have otherwise overlooked. Persuasion can only be construed as
manipulation if the receiving party chooses to avoid independent
investigation. An effective communicator presents a powerful case and hopes
to change the minds of his or her audience; it is his or her job to evoke a
desired response. However, it is up to the audience to analyze the
speaker's position and intelligently reach an independent conclusion. An
audience cannot blame the speaker for presenting a good case.
Only when a speaker provides false or misleading information is a
persuasive argument immoral. If all evidence presented is factual and the
argument is straightforward, then a persuasive speech can enlighten its
listeners, even if the audience chooses to disagree. Persuasion implies a
discussion designed to both educate and to change minds; an effective
rhetorician can deeply impact his or her audience in a positive way.
However, the responsibility still rests with the audience on whether or not
to act on the advice of the speaker....