In the story, Arthur Prime is introduced as the son of a clergyman
and his wife, both of whom have recently died. We first meet Arthur as he
and his cousin, Charlotte, are discussing going through his parent's
belonging after his death. He seems to be reticent to go through the
belongings, telling Charlotte that he wishes she would look at the few new
things he has found. The first impression that the reader gets of Arthur is
that he "seemed somehow to brood without sorrow, to suffer without what she
in her own case would have called pain." This clearly insinuates that he
is shallow and unfeeling, and his disdain of his aunt's "awful" and "cheap"
jewelery shows his disregard for sentimentality at least in this regard.
He is a man concerned with appearances and propriety, and criticizes the
jewels as "trappings of a ruder age than ours. Actors do themselves better
now." He is absolutely insistent that the jewels are worthless, suggesting
that any value would suggest that his aunt was once a 'kept' woman of the
stage, of less than sterling character. As the story moves on, Arthur
reveals himself to be deceptive, as he argues that the pearls are indeed
"rotten paste", and that he does not believe Charlotte's assertion that
they are indeed real and valuable. Rather than standing by his word about
the pearls and returning them to Charlotte, he locks them in a drawer and
says he will have them assessed at Bond Street, simply in order to prove
that they are fakes. It is only later that Charlotte learns through Mrs.
Guy that Arthur has disposed of the pearls by putting them up for sale,
thus deceiving her. Arthur has clearly been portrayed as a man who is
interested in appearances and not generous, he is "one who is unfamiliar
with generosity," and his gift of the pearls is offered in a "tone of
relief which expressed somehow more of the eager than of the gracious."
Ch...