The concrete and spiritual effects of jealousy upon a relationship, in
both the writings of Lady Murasaki and Junichiro Tanizaki, stress that this
emotion can be destructive to the sufferer and to the inflictor. However,
Murasaki's "Tale of Genji" depicts jealousy as almost a mythic force of
nature that propels the plot and the titular hero's life. Some Prefer
Nettles shows jealousy's effects in a far more subtle way.
In Tanizaki, the forces of jealousy, as depicted in the romantic case
of the hero's father, can prove restrictive and smothering to a much
younger but still old-fashioned mistress. However, an absence of jealousy
as exists between the main, married, couple shows a lack of caring and the
death of the relationship. For Tanizaki, jealousy has a dual force for
good and for ill. In "Genji" the effects of jealousy are always for ill,
In the "Tale of Genji," the hero of the tale is essentially born in a
state of jealousy. He is the son of the emperor and the ruler's favorite
concubine. But when a fortuneteller predicts that the baby Genji will
surpass his legitimate brothers and sisters, his mother is persecuted and
eventually dies. Later, during Genji's own romantic exploits, his own wife
tries to leave her own body in spirit so that she can possess and
physically kill her female rival. Genji's lovers are all haunted by Lady
Rokujo, for the spirit of Rokujo is pining for love of the hero.
In Some Prefer Nettles shows how jealousy can have potentially
negative effects. Kaname's father is possessive of his young mistress, and
insists on taking her to old forms of Japanese entertainment, such as the
puppet theater, in an effort to bind her to the world of the old. However
the lack of jealousy Kaname and his wife have in their open' and modern
marriage evidences a lack of caring between the two protagonists.
...