Barbara Hanawalt's, Childrearing Among the Lower Classes of Late
Medieval England, examines the practices and pitfalls of parental dynamics
during the late 13th and early 14th century in English villages such as
Bedfordshire and Oxford, as well as the comparably larger city of London.
Focusing on children's ages from the time of birth till their twelfth
birthday, Hanawalt bases her research on coroner's inquests of the time to
garner statistics from which she extrapolates evidence to support her
conclusions. The coroner's inquests from this time period were required by
law, and detailed in regards to the cause of death, the members of the
household, and their activities at the time, their residences, and their
occupations. Through these detailed transcripts, Hanawalt attempts to
create a vignette of peasant life, and therefore the circumstances in which
children were raised to the age of twelve, at which point they were
considered adults by society during that time.
Hanawalt's motivation for conducting her social type of historical
research is based upon dispelling earlier research by Philippe Aries, in
his book Centuries of Childhood. Aries's book contends that contemporary
sentimental notions of childrearing developed during this time "in response
to the loss of other familial functions to the centralized state and the
exigencies of industrialization" (pg. 23), and that this could outweigh
familial bonds. Hanawalt counters these assertions by methodically
introducing her own conclusions based upon statistical data as well as
detailed circumstances in relation to them. Furthermore, she begins by
pointing out that Aries garners his research and conclusions from the upper
class, while ignoring the peasant majority. Also, she points out that
Aries' research is incomplete due to it starting with children aged seven,
and ignoring ages from infancy till six. Due to the peasant majo...